Profiler Data Supports NASA in Shuttle Columbia Investigation
Figure 1 NOAA Profiler Network and
the Approximate Flight Path of Columbia
|
NOAA's Profiler Network (NPN) Program received requests Monday,
February 03, 2003, from NASA and the National Transportation Safety
Board (NTSB) for NPN upper-air wind data collected during the breakup
of the space shuttle Columbia. Nine of the 35 NPN profiling clear-air
radars, located in the states of New Mexico, Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas
and Louisiana, were near or directly under the flight path of the
shuttle (see Figure 1). Because the unmanned profilers automatically
acquire wind data continuously from near the ground up to 53,000 feet,
the times, horizontal and vertical positions of the falling fragments
of Columbia were captured in the data.
The radar data from the profilers located at Palestine, TX and
Winnfield, LA detected falling fragments from Columbia as it
disintegrated. At Palestine, some larger fragments falling at
speeds of 30 feet per second or more were detected minutes after
NASA lost communications with Columbia. At Winnfield, a fall of
much smaller but far more numerous particles was detected four to
six hours following the breakup. It is likely that some are fine
particles of aluminum from the shuttle's skin and frame, for they
were highly reflective.
NOAA's Forecast Systems Laboratory (FSL) collected NPN data,
reports from dozens of boundary-layer profilers operated by
cooperative agencies, and water vapor data acquired using GPS-based
technology and wrote them onto CD-ROMs. The CDs were sent by
overnight package service to National Weather Service's (NWS)
Southern Region Headquarters in Ft. Worth, TX, which is handling
all coordination with NASA, NTSB and the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA). Staff experts on the NPN will be
available at FSL to provide technical support for the forensic
analysis of the shuttle breakup. The NPN is unique in that no other
observing system can provide the detail of information so critical
for determining the time and space parameters associated with the
Columbia breakup.
The Forecast Systems Laboratory in Boulder, Colorado, operates
and maintains the NPN for NOAA. The National Weather Service
uses data from the 35 network profilers routinely in computer-generated
forecasts, and its field forecasters tailor model guidance to
local conditions. The NPN data are also available on the Global
Telecommunication System for international users, and to everyone
via the World Wide Web at
http://www.profiler.noaa.gov/. Data are
used by many other federal, state and local organizations for support
in weather forecasting, aviation, and monitoring climate and air quality.
One of NPN's customers is Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory,
which uses NPN data as critical input to its dispersion model.
The model supports work under contract to the Departments of Defense
and Energy for Homeland Security.
|
|
Hide Markers
Figure 2 PATT2 10-21 UTC
|
Figure 2 shows typical winds measured by a Profiler, plotted once
every hour from near the earth's surface to above 50,000 feet.
Wind speeds are color coded, and the wind direction is identified
by the angle of each of the "flag and barbs" displayed. (More
information is available at
http://www.profiler.noaa.gov/npn/aboutProfilerData.jsp.)
Note the changing wind speed and direction, most apparent at
the lower elevations (below about 500 mb, or 18,000 ft). This shows
the typical meteorological use, or aspect of the data. In this case,
the Palestine, TX profiler wind data were actually measured around the
time of the accident (2/1/03 14:00 UTC). Note the missing wind data
centered around 45,000 ft at 15:00 UTC. The falling pieces of the shuttle
caused this area of missing data in the hourly averaged winds (acquired
between 14:00 and 15:00 UTC).
|
Figure 3 PATT2 12-17 UTC
|
Figure 3 shows a very unique view "looking upward" above the Palestine profiler site.
The measured vertical velocities are displayed as color; yellow to red colors
for downward motion, and blue to purple as upward motion. Vertical velocity data
are measured by the Profiler once every 6 minutes. A rather consistent pattern
of downward falling objects are apparent above about 45,000 ft immediately
following the time of the shuttle breakup (~14:00 UTC). Many of these objects
are falling with a velocity of 25-35 ft/s, but apparently still have much larger
horizontal velocities and pass quickly through the four degree wide radar beam.
Note that objects appear to continue to fall through the radar beam for about
30 minutes.
|
Figure 4 PATT2 12-17 UTC
|
Figure 4 displays the signal power reflected by the atmosphere or objects,
for the same time period as Figure 3. The horizontal discontinuity in signal
power at 25,000 ft is a normal change in the radar sensitivity. Meteorological
signals are generally slowly changing with time and height, for example the
layer at 36,000 - 39,000 ft. Aircraft or other objects appear as higher power
returns confined to a single time period. Note the area of enhanced signal
power returns above 25,000 ft following the time of the shuttle breakup (~14:00 UTC).
These enhanced signals are apparently from the falling objects as they passed
over the site.
|
Figure 5 WNFL1 14-22 UTC
|
Figure 5 shows the very unique view "looking upward" above the Winnfield, LA (
WNFL1) profiler site, located about 250 miles east (downwind) of Palestine,TX.
The measured vertical velocity scale has been change from Figure 3, and now
displays downward velocities of 3 - 6 ft/s as yellow to red colors. The time
axis has also been changed. The time of the accident is now displayed at the
far right-hand edge of the plot. Nothing unusual is apparent for approximately
4.5 hours. Then a rather consistent pattern of downward falling objects appear
from 25,000 - 50,000 ft above the site. These are apparently the much smaller
particles falling at about the speed of a snow flake (~3 - 5 ft/s), hence the
delay in time to fall from ~200,000 to 50,000 feet. In this case, as the particles
are slowly falling downward they are also being advected horizontally by the
normal atmospheric winds blowing generally from the west toward the east. The
particles continue falling through the atmosphere, but "outside" the vertically
pointing radar beam and end up downwind of the site. Although these are much
smaller particles, it is interesting to note their distribution in time and height.
In this figure, the heavier weight particles are detected first in time and at
height of approximately 40,000 ft. Particles appear to fall for approximately three
hours. The lighter weight particles appear later in time and at generally higher
altitudes, consistent with them falling more slowly through the upper atmosphere.
|
Figure 6 WNFL1 14-22 UTC
|
Figure 6 displays the signal power reflected by the atmosphere or objects,
for the same time period as Figure 5, above the Winnfield, LA profiler site.
Again, the horizontal discontinuity in signal power at 25,000 ft is a normal
change in the radar sensitivity, and meteorological signals are generally slowly
changing with time and height. Aircraft or other objects appear as higher power
returns confined to a single time period. Note the area of enhanced signal power
returns from 25,000 - 50,000 ft after 18:00 UTC. These enhanced signals are
apparently from the falling particles as they passed over the site.
|
External Links
The initial release of this story on the NOAA Web Site
Denver's 9News story on Profilers contribution to NASA's Shuttle Columbia investigation
|
|